The Clearsale Blog

7 Ways Automated Fraud Protection Can Fail You

7 Ways Automated Fraud Protection Can Fail You

Automated fraud protection systems – such as the fraud filters that are often integrated within e-commerce platforms – have historically been the most popular ways for e-commerce merchants to prevent potentially fraudulent orders from processing. After all, fraud filters are a relatively inexpensive solution that can quickly analyze a vast amount of transactional data.

But times are changing, and so are the most effective approaches to fraud prevention. The algorithms used in fraud filters and other automated fraud prevention systems may no longer be enough to provide the level of security a growing e-commerce retailer needs.

Why is this approach, which has been used for so long, decreasing in effectiveness?

The Major Drawbacks of Automated Fraud Protection

There are many reasons automated solutions can cost e-retailers profits and customers, including:

1. They Have High Rates of False Declines

One of the biggest problems merchants experience with these automatic systems is ensuring legitimate transactions are approved while fraudulent ones are declined: LexisNexis reports that fraud filters have a false positive rate of approximately 25%, costing merchants $118 billion in 2015.

2. They Use Incomplete Data Sets

These systems generally make decisions based on limited amounts of transactional information, so they can’t account for situational changes. For example, if a business establishes a rule that automatically declines transactions when the billing address is different from the shipping address, they may inadvertently reject an order a customer is buying as a gift for a family member.

3. They’re Rarely Customized

Fraud filters can’t pick up on the fraud approaches that are unique to individual businesses or industries. Instead, they typically apply the same set of rules to all businesses.

4. They’re Ineffective if Improperly Layered

If fraud filters aren’t optimized, they can limit sales and increase false declines. And if merchants add one filter on top of another filter without thinking about the order in which the filters will be applies, certain rules may override other rules — reducing or even eliminating their overall effectiveness and either allowing fraudulent orders to pass through or incorrectly flagging legitimate orders as fraudulent.

5. They May Be Resource-Intensive

Although these solutions may be automated in the way they evaluate transactions, they still require constant maintenance and dedicated human staff to ensure the various rules are up to date and being applied properly.

6. They May Be Too Strict

While merchants might think that the strictest possible security measures provide the best protection, they’re only half right. Strict rules may miss fewer fraudulent transactions, but they’re also more likely to falsely decline legitimate transactions. Strict systems can also slow down order response times, increasing customer frustration and checkout abandonment.

7. They Aren’t Self-Learning

This is perhaps most important but least understood by merchants: some automated fraud systems don’t use past experience to improve future decisions. Once a rule is set, it’s set. If a fraudster understands the rules a merchant has in place, it’s easy for the fraudster to exploit them.

Fraudsters are always increasing the sophistication of their attack methods. A common tactic is to make subtle changes to existing threats and malware. These tiny changes to coding produce new threats that are virtually undetectable by software — including automated fraud protection methods. So while automated systems may be effective at picking up major fraud trends, they’re less effective at detecting emerging fraud strategies and small-scale attacks.

Even if the automated systems could pick up on the slight changes and new patterns, they’re not sophisticated enough to incorporate these new fraud strategies into their algorithms on their own and use them to identify and prevent future attacks.

So … if automated systems aren’t the end-all-be-all many merchants believe them to be, what should merchants do instead?

A Better Approach to Fraud Protection

With so many parts of e-commerce business going high-tech, it’s no surprise that merchants are looking for a technology-based solution to screen their transactions. Unfortunately, with a simple automated fraud protection system, merchants often find themselves vulnerable to lost profits due to false declines, fraudulent transactions and chargebacks.

Instead, merchants should consider a hybrid solution: expert human analysis combined with advanced artificial intelligence (AI). The AI system continually analyzes and processes high-level features from raw data. Then the analysts add value by adding data points, transaction results and incident details into the AI system, making it smarter and more effective.

Together, the hybrid system becomes nearly foolproof.

At ClearSale, we combine data analytics, statistical intelligence and human expertise to help e-commerce merchants improve fraud protection while maximizing sales. Learn more about the different fraud protection tools available to you, and then contact us to find out how our unique approach can benefit your business.

ClearSale Fraud Protection Buyers Guide

You may also like

ClearSale Recognized with 2021 Comparably Award for Best Company Outlook

ClearSale Recognized with 2021 Comparably Award for Best Company Outlook

Fraud protection leader ranked among businesses for high employee confidence and successful outlook

Mobile Application and Microtransaction Fraud: What It Is, How to Prevent It

Mobile Application and Microtransaction Fraud: What It Is, How to Prevent It

The exponential growth in digital commerce has made it easier and more convenient than ever for consumers to engage with brands.

One way they’re doing this is through mobile applications. While..

Critical Pandemic Lessons in Mobile Payment Fraud Prevention

Critical Pandemic Lessons in Mobile Payment Fraud Prevention

As the world pivoted to online shopping, work, and learning last year, the timeline for mobile usage growth jumped ahead by two to three years in the first half of 2020. Many retailers rolled out..

QR Code Payments Are Convenient, Great for Distancing, and Targets for Fraud

QR Code Payments Are Convenient, Great for Distancing, and Targets for Fraud

QR code payments have finally caught on in the U.S. after lagging behind adoption in China and other Asian markets. Why the change? The need for contactless payments brought on by the pandemic..

ClearSale Nominated for “Best Business Process Outsourcing” in the NORA Awards

ClearSale Nominated for “Best Business Process Outsourcing” in the NORA Awards

Retail association recognizes ClearSale’s valuable fraud protection services for businesses worldwide.

Advance Strategies to Eliminate Ecommerce Chargebacks

Advance Strategies to Eliminate Ecommerce Chargebacks

What can we expect e-commerce to look like throughout 2021? There's still a lot of uncertainty in the economy, but some strong trends emerged last year that merchants can build upon now as..

Not-For-Profits and Charities Are High-Risk Targets for Costly BIN-Bashing Fraud. Here’s What to Do About It

Not-For-Profits and Charities Are High-Risk Targets for Costly BIN-Bashing Fraud. Here’s What to Do About It

By Ralph Kooi, Australia Country Manager, ClearSale and Matt Humphries, Head of Sales and Marketing, Bambora

As UK Stores Target a Global Audience, Here’s What You Need to Know About Security

As UK Stores Target a Global Audience, Here’s What You Need to Know About Security

The sharp rise of eCommerce has eliminated shopping borders and it's not unusual for hackers to target stores not in their local country to avoid outing themselves.

What You Need to Know in Ecommerce

What You Need to Know in Ecommerce

The past year or so has changed how we shop and how we think. As the world changes and as consumer behaviour changes with it, as merchants we must start to ask ourselves, very seriously, will our..

Want to write
for our blog?

Please review our writers' guidelines
https://www2.clear.sale/press/clearsale-guest-blog-guidelines
and then email guestwriter@clear.sale with your pitch!

Subscribe to our blog